
Mission Statement:
To endeavor to bring to all residents of the Five States the most current and important news from across the entire Five States region. Never yellow, the Five States Herald vows to serve only the people of the Five States, from New Austin to Lemoyne, free of charge now and forever.
Letter from the editor:
Dear readers,
This week’s issue marks a turning point in the Herald’s early life. We have heard your feedback, we have heard what you want. And while we take no money from you, your readership we do desire. To that end, the Herald shall make a few small changes. You may have already noticed the more concise mission statement, but we have also have sent to our reporters new field cameras. When the opportunity arises, and enough time is afforded, they may provide photographs of that which they report on.
Further, this issue debuts a new layout that will be featured from time to time when there are too many big stories to be contained in a single front page article. With three main stories, the Herald received a minor modification to its layout to accompany it. No doubt as the Five States region continues to grow this layout will be more needed than ever.
Lastly, this article marks a moment in which the Herald takes a stance for free speech. As a member of the press, it should be obvious that we are committed to free speech, without which this paper and many others would be unreliable propaganda for the powers that be. In France, an author criticized the French government for a possible coverup. He published a letter in the French newspaper L’Aurore and was subsequently arrested. This is something that cannot stand. In solidarity, we reprint an English translation of that very open letter, so that France’s allies, such as the U.S., may know the disdain the country shows for free speech.
We will continue to adapt with the times and sincerely hope you enjoy the changes as well.
– William Warrington III, Editor in Chief
Federal Government Launches Gunfighter fueled Assault on Lawlessness in Five States Region
By Doc Deschain (Freelancer)
The U.S Government this week passed a bill to allow the state sanctioned licensing of civilian bounty hunters to operate in the Five States. The move comes after months of lawless rampaging across the territory by outlaws and unscrupulous frontiersmen trying to build their wealth off the misfortune of others. Shootouts and civilian massacres have become a routine occurrence in developing towns, such as Valentine and Blackwater, where the local authorities have been powerless to stop them.
Now, the government is fighting back with the financial backing of the BHTC. Bounty hunting has long been a profession in the West but has always been strictly limited to a few trusted and controlled individuals. The weight of law keeping has always rested heavily on the shoulders of the authorities and police force. This latest Bill, the so called, Summer Bill, is set to change all that forever. The Five States promises to be a safer place for all civilians, and we should start seeing some of our blackest hearted criminals being brought to justice. There is no word whether this will have any impact on the beleaguered Del Lobos gang in Thieves Landing and whether this protection extends to them.
The Five States Herald has been advised that those seeking to buy a license to bounty hunt should report to the Rhodes Sheriff’s Office without delay.
New Austin
No one permitted to leave New Austin
By Elois Burditt
The authorities gave the order to not let anyone near the border under any circumstance this week. People planning to go on a trip into Mexico will need to cancel. The warning comes as three soldiers and five bounty hunters were found dead near the Mexico border not far from Tumbleweed. Sheriff Freeman has not given a statement but I have learned that it is believed that the Mexican Revolutionary Group Los Libertadores is responsible.
The Mexican government is working with the US Government and the Pinkterton agency to bring to justice Miguel de la Rosa, a prominent member of Los Libertadores. A reward of $3,000 is promised to any person who provides the information that leads to de la Rosa’s arrrest.
Thieves Landing Triplets stun many

By Wylie Frey
Rumor of a set of triplets in Thieves Landing has drawn the interest of many to an area not known to be friendly. It is not that surprising given the rarity of triplets in this world. Most people do not know what to make of the brothers at first, and have mistaken them as the same person when they are not standing together.
The brothers have managed to turn their mild attraction into a means of obtaining free booze. While few are willing to pay them directly for their stories, many seem to have no problem paying for their drinks to keep them talking.
Write for the Herald!
Do you explore every nook and cranny five states? Good with a typewriter and a camera? You might have what it takes to write for the Five States Herald. Apply today!
Wild shootout at Pike’s Basin
By Wylie Frey
Residents of MacFarlane’s Ranch in Hennigan’s Stead were awoken one night this week to the sound of gunfire. The shots were coming from Pike’s Basin, just west of the ranch. Hennigan’s Stead is typically quiet, but on this night gun shots echoed. Pike’s Basin is basically a giant hole in the ground used by outlaws to hide out. A couple who was staying at the ranch for a night was very startled, but did not see the fight. They were packing to leave the next day while I tried to question them.
The only visual details come from a pair of children, who sneaked their way to the edge of the basin and took a peak. They described three or four people coming in and laying waste to the outlaws and leave, with one of the attackers carrying a man away. Explosions and more gunshots were heard, but the children lost sight of them as they went deeper into the basin. Neither the Armadillo Sheriff nor the New Austin Marshall responded to a request for a comment.
Ambarino
Adventurer scales glacier and falls to death
By Caylen V. Hornby
An unnamed man tried to make his claim to fame this week. He scaled the glacier in the northernmost reaches of Grizzlies West. Many expeditions have explored the area, but this man decided to scale it using special boots and gloves that had metal hooks attached.
It is unknown when the man started, or how long he had been lying on the ground before he was found. A few explorers scouting the area found the man and were astonished to learn that he was still alive, but only just. They did the best they could to comfort him but he passed soon after while at their camp near a warm fire. Given his condition he never spoke, but seamed to be at peace to be around people.
West Elizabeth
Bounty hunter sets “the Hangmen” up to be hanged
By Ela Q. Asken
While in Strawberry this week continuing investigations into the mayor, I saw the new bounty hunting initiative in full force. I noticed a man in mostly grey and black carefully study the bounty board before ripping a poster off. The bounty hunter rode out and so I spoke with the sheriff. I wanted to find out who was being hunted and who was doing the hunting.

Having taken a picture of the board earlier in the day, I was able to easily identify who the targets were, but I wanted to know more. Turns out, “The Hangmen” were dangerous men known for hanging their victims. At least 13 people have died by their hands. The sheriff informed me that most of their crimes were committed in the South, though that bit is downplayed as the government continues to put a positive spin on the unity of the nation. These are the types of men the bounty hunter initiative is bringing to Justice.
“These ain’t the kinda folks you want in or around your town. When I heard they were seen in the area, we put a bounty out immediately,” said the sheriff. Of the bounty hunter, “Cross? Good man. Brings them in alive most of the time, but nobody is perfect.” Beyond the name Nathaniel Cross, I was able to find little else. The sheriff had little to say besides the man being a diligent “hunter of men” and “more or less a pleasure to be around, mostly cuz he don’t say much.” Cross came back into town riding a wagon with both Hangmen in the back screaming obscenities and making threats. The sheriff was already preparing the gallows.
New trade opportunities not without consequences
By Adam Parvey
Enterprise and the free market are on the rise! Cowpokes all over the Five States are have taken advantage of the massive investment from the BHTC to purchase the necessary components to run a successful business. Butchers tables along with wagons of various sizes have been selling quicker than ever before. This comes as a great relief to the leaders of the BHTC, who were unsure if their investment would pay off in the long term. Now that it seems certain that many businesses are taking off, more should succeed than fail. That means the investors at the BHTC should get more than their money’s worth.
As of press time, many hunters have complained however that the increase in businesses dealing in animal parts have left many areas without game to hunt. A representative from BHTC commented on the potential over hunting of game, “We cannot simply restock animals, thus we must consider keeping viable populations of animals alive. That said, we are confident that the free market will remedy this problem. A massive influx of parts is only going to drop prices, and push some businesses out of the market. Once these growing pains are through, we should see balance in the animal kingdom.”
This of course was of little comfort to those looking to make quick cash. Some have resorted to obtaining a bounty hunter’s license and taken to hunting humans instead of animals. Still, there have been complaints about bounties not being paid, leading to many would be bounty hunters retiring before their career fully got underway. The BHTC seems confident that these issues will sort themselves out in the long run and have assured those taking advantage of the new jobs be patient.
New Hanover
Wagon Theft leaves fledgling trader in a desperate position
By Emery Cosberry
A fellow who decided to take advantage of the new jobs expansion in the five states applied for and was able to purchase the necessary start up items, such as a small wagon and a butcher table. “Started off pretty good, right? I mean, I’m a decent hunter. Getting the stuff to the market is the hard part,” said Rube Pibern. Mr. Pibern had been in the middle of making a delivery to a customer in Heartland Overflow when a couple of intimidating cowpokes set upon him.
“I was alone, figured the route to a local buyer would be safe, I was wrong.” Mr. Pibern did not put up a fight and stepped off the wagon, letting the two cowpokes ride off with it. “I ain’t no rube… well I mean I am a Rube by name but I ain’t a rube. You know what I mean!” Mr. Pibern was undeterred initially and met with his buyer to inform him the shipment would be delayed. Unfortunately, Mr. Pibern was then informed that the buyer already purchased what he needed at a much lower price from two rough looking cowpokes looking to unload just what the buyer was looking for.
“What could I do? They already bought the stuff, but it did look awfully like the supplies I was bringing,” Said Mr. Pibern.
Pike Fishing Booms in Valentine
By Doc Deschain (Freelancer)
The cattle town of Valentine, New Hanover has seen a sharp increase in the demand for Northern Pike in recent weeks. The Pike, a valuable fish species, is transported across New Hanover to markets in Saint Denis where it fetches a good price of $8.00 on the open market. Valentine has found itself in the center of this trade due to its proximity to the Dakota River where Northern Pike are abundant. The result of this has been a sharp increase in fisherman along the Dakota where there is a killing to be made in the pike trade. This reporter’s advice from one such individual: take along with you two horses to maximize profits or a hunting wagon if you have the resources. There’s no need to travel very far, just southwest of Valentine is a popular spot for anyone looking to make a quick $16.
The New Hanover Ecological Society is currently investigating the environmental impact this increased fishing will have on the Norther Pike population in New Hanover, but it certainly shows no sign of slowing. Detractors of the Society cite generous spawns in the environment as being key to understanding the senselessness of the investigation. The Society could not be reached for comment on this.
Lemoyne
Pack of wolves terrorize Bolger Glade area
By Mathilde Orrey
Bolger Glade is a curious place. To locals it is a reminder of great Confederate victories, but also of their ultimate defeat. To many travelers, it is the closest they will ever get to true warfare. Many are drawn to the history of this place and certain types of folks, who fancy themselves collectors, come looking for treasures long forgotten. However, trips to Bolger Glade have an increased risk these days as a pack of wolves with a very large alpha has been seen roaming the area. Word is a fellow in Rhodes is willing to pay to have the wolves cleared out.
Monkeyshines Trilogy public viewing
By Aloysius Levron
If you have a spare ten minutes and money to waste, stop by the Fontana Theater in Saint Denis, where screenings of the Monkeyshines Trilogy will take place for the next several weeks. While only seconds long, each film in the series is a proof of concept and the very first films every created in these United States. Indeed, it is a rare treat to view this small snippet of history.
Grief stricken mother determined to find child
By Mathilde Orry
In our first issue of the Five States Herald, I wrote about the Rudnab family, who vacationed in the bayou and lost their son. The Rudnab’s temporarily relocated to Scarlett Meadows to continue their search for their lost son. Mrs Rudnab chose the location due to its proximity to the bayou, close enough to search daily but far enough away for the rest of the children to be safe.
The latter seems to be true, as no other children have gone mission. However, the search continues without any sign of the boy. Because she fears the boy kidnapped and refuses to acknowledge the possibility of the boy being killed by the bayou wildlife, Mrs. Rudnab often spends days in Saint Denis. She scrutinizes every child that walks by and on more than one occasion has accused someone of kidnapping.
“They all look like him. Don’t you understand? They all look like him!” was all she said when asked for a comment. Losing a child is certainly enough to break a woman and it looks like Mrs. Rudnab is starting to break. For her sake, and for the sake of the rest of her child, I hope she finds peace soon. Mr. Rudnab spends his days in Rhodes, mostly in the saloon.
Bounty Hunters Wanted!
Good with a gun? Do some good for your community and become a Bounty Hunter. Apply at the Rhodes sheriff office. Costs: 15 gold bars.
Madam Nazar offering a new path to riches
By Nick McCrary
A traveling gypsy woman named Madam Nazar has been seen across the five states. The appearance of this exotic woman has peaked the interest of many and those who have met her have learned she has come to the five states as part of the BHTC jobs initiative. Madam Nazar is an expert in “the unknown” and appears to dabble in mysticism as well as artifacts. If it is her mystic secrets you want, you might as well move on. She is not here to share them.

However, for those interested in exploration and artifacts, Madam Nazar is ready to guide you on a path most cowpokes hardly even consider. What Madam Nazar needs with all of these artifacts she will not say, however she is well funded and able to pay top dollar for items on her list. For most, that’s enough to sate their curiosity about Madam Nazar’s intentions. A curious note is that Madam Nazar was not in contact with the United States Congress back when they were responsible for the jobs bill. The BHTC chose her in large part because she is self funded and did not need BHTC funds to make her acquisitions. For some, this is even more troubling as they question where should could have obtained so much money.
Further, why is she not afraid of being robbed? She often sets up camp far away from civilization and she has no guards around her wagon. For that matter, she does not even have a nearby horse to move the wagon. How does she move it? And how does she keep would be thieves away?
Whatever her motives and the answers to these questions, many are now on a path to help her in her plans. So long as she keeps the money flowing, it is likely cowpokes will continue to sell her eggs, arrowheads, mundane objects, and more. If you would like to start the path of a collector, you’ll need to seek out Madam Nazar. That is easier said than done, of course. Madama Nazar bores of one spot quickly and so she is constantly on the move in a new place every day.
Across the Nation
Death of a feminist leaves many in mourning
By Adam Parvey
Joslyn Gage died this week. She was a prominent feminist advocating for women’s right to vote. However, she was more than a feminist. Gage was also a passionate abolitionists and tirelessly campaigned for Indian rights. It must have been a wild ride last week, as Gage no doubt would have been pleased to have the citizenship guarantee of the 14th Amendment held up by the Supreme Court. However, Lemoyne’s new state constitution is likely something she would have been adamantly against. In fact, one of her friends said she had just written a letter to the Lemoyne governor condemning the disenfranchisement of black Americans. An activist to the end.
First American-made automobile sold
By Adam Parvey
Many folks are eagerly watching this new transportation technology called the automobile. “You need to know how to ride a horse properly to use one, right? But a car? You just get in it and go!” was the sales pitch I heard. A gentleman named Robert Allenson of Pennsylvania decided to put his faith in this new technology and purchased the very first American-made automobile!
“It’s amazing! I can feel the power of the automobile. That’s power, right? The shaking?” Mr. Allenson drove around slowly and made very wide turns. What seemed like a very simple endeavor appeared to be quite complicated indeed as Mr. Allenson struggled to keep the car straight.
Around the Globe
Hawaii annexed into the US
By Ivy Seager
The Republic of Hawaii has been formally annexed into the United States and has become the Hawaii Territory. The island is formerly a sovereign nation in its own right. The Hawaiian Kingdom formed in 1795 and included most of the surrounding islands. It expanded in 1810 to include the rest of the islands. The United States, as their chief trading partner, offered protected it from other island nations.
In 1887 the Hawaiian Kingdom came to a formal end when it adopted a new constitutions under threat of force. From this time until its annexation, Hawaii was a Republic led by leaders who largely viewed themselves as American. Well now all Hawaiians are Americans.
Author jailed for speech
By Ivy Seager
Members of the press have much in common. While we are in competition for readers’ time, we respect each other and the struggle against the powers that be and their attempt hide the truth. It is in this spirit, that we republish an open letter first published in in the French paper L’Aurore at the end of this week’s issue, translated in English for the first time. The author of the letter, Émile Zola, was charged for libel for criticizing the French government for covering up the false conviction of Alfred Dreyfus. Mr. Zola is currently in jail awaiting sentencing. While our reprinting of this letter will not likely have great effect in France, it is enough to know that our fellow members of the press will know that they are not alone.
J’Accuse
Mr. President,
Would you allow me, in my gratitude for the benevolent reception that you gave me one day, to draw the attention of your rightful glory and to tell you that your star, so happy until now, is threatened by the most shameful and most ineffaceable of blemishes?
You have passed healthy and safe through base calumnies; you have conquered hearts. You appear radiant in the apotheosis of this patriotic festival that the Russian alliance was for France, and you prepare to preside over the solemn triumph of our World Fair, which will crown our great century of work, truth and freedom. But what a spot of mud on your name—I was going to say on your reign—is this abominable Dreyfus affair! A council of war, under order, has just dared to acquit Esterhazy, a great blow to all truth, all justice. And it is finished, France has this stain on her cheek, History will write that it was under your presidency that such a social crime could be committed.
Since they dared, I too will dare. The truth I will say, because I promised to say it, if justice, regularly seized, did not do it, full and whole. My duty is to speak, I do not want to be an accomplice. My nights would be haunted by the specter of innocence that suffer there, through the most dreadful of tortures, for a crime it did not commit.
And it is to you, Mr. President, that I will proclaim it, this truth, with all the force of the revulsion of an honest man. For your honour, I am convinced that you are unaware of it. And with whom will I thus denounce the criminal foundation of these guilty truths, if not with you, the first magistrate of the country?
First, the truth about the lawsuit and the judgment of Dreyfus.
A nefarious man carried it all out, did everything: Lieutenant Colonel Du Paty de Clam, at that time only a Commandant. He is the entirety of the Dreyfus business; it will be known only when one honest investigation clearly establishes his acts and responsibilities. He seems a most complicated and hazy spirit, haunting romantic intrigues, caught up in serialised stories, stolen papers, anonymous letters, appointments in deserted places, mysterious women who sell condemning evidences at night. It is he who imagined dictating the Dreyfus memo; it is he who dreamed to study it in an entirely hidden way, under ice; it is him whom commander Forzinetti describes to us as armed with a dark lantern, wanting to approach the sleeping defendant, to flood his face abruptly with light and to thus surprise his crime, in the agitation of being roused. And I need hardly say that that what one seeks, one will find. I declare simply that commander Du Paty de Clam, charged to investigate the Dreyfus business as a legal officer, is, in date and in responsibility, the first culprit in the appalling miscarriage of justice committed.
The memo was for some time already in the hands of Colonel Sandherr, director of the office of information, who has since died of general paresis. “Escapes” took place, papers disappeared, as they still do today; the author of the memo was sought, when ahead of time one was made aware, little by little, that this author could be only an officer of the High Comman and an artillery officer: a doubly glaring error, showing with which superficial spirit this affair had been studied, because a reasoned examination shows that it could only be a question of an officer of troops. Thus searching the house, examining writings, it was like a family matter, a traitor to be surprised in the same offices, in order to expel him. And, while I do not want to retell a partly known history here, Commander Paty de Clam enters the scene, as soon as first suspicion falls upon Dreyfus. From this moment, it is he who invented Dreyfus, the affair becomes that affair, made actively to confuse the traitor, to bring him to a full confession. There is the Minister of War, General Mercier, whose intelligence seems poor; there are the head of the High Command, General De Boisdeffre, who appears to have yielded to his clerical passion, and the assistant manager of the High Command, General Gonse, whose conscience could put up with many things. But, at the bottom, there is initially only Commander Du Paty de Clam, who carries them all out, who hypnotizes them, because he deals also with spiritism, with occultism, conversing with spirits. One could not conceive of the experiments to which he subjected unhappy Dreyfus, the traps into which he wanted to make him fall, the insane investigations, monstrous imaginations, a whole torturing insanity.
Ah! this first affair is a nightmare for those who know its true details! Commander Du Paty de Clam arrests Dreyfus, in secret. He turns to Mrs. Dreyfus, terrorises her, says to her that, if she speaks, her husband is lost. During this time, the unhappy one tore his flesh, howled his innocence. And the instructions were made thus, as in a 15th century tale, shrouded in mystery, with a savage complication of circumstances, all based on only one childish charge, this idiotic affair, which was not only a vulgar treason, but was also the most impudent of hoaxes, because the famously delivered secrets were almost all without value. If I insist, it is that the kernel is here, from whence the true crime will later emerge, the terrible denial of justice from which France is sick. I would like to touch with a finger on how this miscarriage of justice could be possible, how it was born from the machinations of Commander Du Paty de Clam, how General Mercier, General De Boisdeffre and General Gonse could be let it happen, to engage little by little their responsibility in this error, that they believed a need, later, to impose like the holy truth, a truth which is not even discussed. At the beginning, there is not this, on their part, this incuriosity and obtuseness. At most, one feels them to yield to an ambiance of religious passions and the prejudices of the physical spirit. They allowed themselves a mistake.
But here Dreyfus is before the council of war. Closed doors are absolutely required. A traitor would have opened the border with the enemy to lead the German emperor to Notre-Dame, without taking measures to maintain narrow silence and mystery. The nation is struck into a stupor, whispering of terrible facts, monstrous treasons which make History indignant; naturally the nation is so inclined. There is no punishment too severe, it will applaud public degradation, it will want the culprit to remain on his rock of infamy, devoured by remorse. Is this then true, the inexpressible things, the dangerous things, capable of plunging Europe into flames, which one must carefully bury behind these closed doors? No! There was behind this, only the romantic and lunatic imaginations of Commander Paty de Clam. All that was done only to hide the most absurd of novella plots. And it suffices, to ensure oneself of this, to study with attention the bill of indictment, read in front of the council of war.
Ah! the nothingness of this bill of indictment! That a man could be condemned for this act, is a wonder of iniquity. I defy decent people to read it, without their hearts leaping in indignation and shouting their revolt, while thinking of the unwarranted suffering, over there, on Devil’s Island. Dreyfus knows several languages, crime; one found at his place no compromising papers, crime; he returns sometimes to his country of origin, crime; he is industrious, he wants to know everything, crime; he is unperturbed, crime; he is perturbed, crime. And the naiveté of drafting formal assertions in a vacuum! One spoke to us of fourteen charges: we find only one in the final analysis, that of the memo; and we even learn that the experts did not agree, than one of them, Mr. Gobert, was coerced militarily, because he did not allow himself to reach a conclusion in the desired direction. One also spoke of twenty-three officers who had come to overpower Dreyfus with their testimonies. We remain unaware of their interrogations, but it is certain that they did not all charge him; and it is to be noticed, moreover, that all belonged to the war offices. It is a family lawsuit, one is there against oneself, and it is necessary to remember this: the High Command wanted the lawsuit, it was judged, and it has just judged it a second time.
Therefore, there remained only the memo, on which the experts had not concurred. It is reported that, in the room of the council, the judges were naturally going to acquit. And consequently, as one includes/understands the despaired obstinacy with which, to justify the judgment, today the existence of a secret part is affirmed, overpowering, the part which cannot be shown, which legitimates all, in front of which we must incline ourselves, the good invisible and unknowable God! I deny it, this part, I deny it with all my strength! A ridiculous part, yes, perhaps the part wherein it is a question of young women, and where a certain D… is spoken of which becomes too demanding: some husband undoubtedly finding that his wife did not pay him dearly enough. But a part interesting the national defense, which one could not produce without war being declared tomorrow, no, no! It is a lie! and it is all the more odious and cynical that they lie with impunity without one being able to convince others of it. They assemble France, they hide behind its legitimate emotion, they close mouths by disturbing hearts, by perverting spirits. I do not know a greater civic crime.
Here then, Mr. President, are the facts which explain how a miscarriage of justice could be made; and the moral evidence, the financial circumstances of Dreyfus, the absence of reason, his continual cry of innocence, completes its demonstration as a victim of the extraordinary imaginations of commander Du Paty de Clam, of the clerical medium in which it was found, of the hunting for the “dirty Jews”, which dishonours our time.
And we arrive at the Esterhazy affair. Three years passed, many consciences remain deeply disturbed, worry, seek, end up being convinced of Dreyfus’s innocence.
I will not give the history of the doubts and of the conviction of Mr. Scheurer-Kestner. But, while this was excavated on the side, it ignored serious events among the High Command. Colonel Sandherr was dead, and Major Picquart succeeded him as head of the office of the information. And it was for this reason, in the performance of his duties, that the latter one day found in his hands a letter-telegram, addressed to commander Esterhazy, from an agent of a foreign power. His strict duty was to open an investigation. It is certain that he never acted apart from the will of his superiors. He thus submitted his suspicions to his seniors in rank, General Gonse, then General De Boisdeffre, then General Billot, who had succeeded General Mercier as the Minister of War. The infamous Picquart file, about which so much was said, was never more than a Billot file, a file made by a subordinate for his minister, a file which must still exist within the Ministry of War. Investigations ran from May to September 1896, and what should be well affirmed is that General Gonse was convinced of Esterhazy’s guilt, and that Generals De Boisdeffre and Billot did not question that the memo was written by Esterhazy. Major Picquart’s investigation had led to this unquestionable observation. But the agitation was large, because the condemnation of Esterhazy inevitably involved the revision of Dreyfus’s trial; and this, the High Command did not want at any cost.
There must have been a minute full of psychological anguish. Notice that General Billot was in no way compromised, he arrived completely fresh, he could decide the truth. He did not dare, undoubtedly in fear of public opinion, certainly also in fear of betraying all the High Command, General De Boisdeffre, General Gonse, not mentioning those of lower rank. Therefore there was only one minute of conflict between his conscience and what he believed to be the military’s interest. Once this minute had passed, it was already too late. He had engaged, he was compromised. And, since then, his responsibility only grew, he took responsibility for the crimes of others, he became as guilty as the others, he was guiltier than them, because he was the Master of justice, and he did nothing. Understand that! Here for a year General Billot, General De Boisdeffre and General Gonse have known that Dreyfus is innocent, and they kept this appalling thing to themselves! And these people sleep at night, and they have women and children whom they love!
Major Picquart had fulfilled his duty as an honest man. He insisted to his superiors, in the name of justice. He even begged them, he said to them how much their times were ill-advised, in front of the terrible storm which was to pour down, which was to burst, when the truth would be known. It was, later, the language that Mr. Scheurer-Kestner also used with General Billot, entreating him with patriotism to take the affair in hand, not to let it worsen, on the verge of becoming a public disaster. No! The crime had been committed, the High Command could no longer acknowledge its crime. And Major Picquart was sent on a mission, one that took him farther and farther away, as far as Tunisia, where there was not even a day to honour his bravery, charged with a mission which would have surely ended in massacre, in the frontiers where Marquis de Morès met his death. He was not in disgrace, General Gonse maintained a friendly correspondence with him. It is only about secrets he was not good to have discovered.
To Paris, the truth inexorably marched, and it is known how the awaited storm burst. Mr. Mathieu Dreyfus denounced commander Esterhazy as the true author of the memo just as Mr. Scheurer-Kestner demanded a revision of the case to the Minister of Justice. And it is here that commander Esterhazy appears. Testimony shows him initially thrown into a panic, ready for suicide or escape. Then, at a blow, he acted with audacity, astonishing Paris by the violence of his attitude. It is then that help had come to him, he had received an anonymous letter informing him of the work of his enemies, a mysterious lady had come under cover of night to return a stolen evidence against him to the High Command, which would save him. And I cannot help but find Major Paty de Clam here, considering his fertile imagination. His work, Dreyfus’s culpability, was in danger, and he surely wanted to defend his work. The retrial was the collapse of such an extravagant novella, so tragic, whose abominable outcome takes place in Devil’s Island! This is what he could not allow. Consequently, a duel would take place between Major Picquart and Major Du Paty de Clam, one with face uncovered, the other masked. They will soon both be found before civil justice. In the end, it was always the High Command that defended itself, that did not want to acknowledge its crime; the abomination grew hour by hour.
One wondered with astonishment who were protecting commander Esterhazy. It was initially, in the shadows, Major Du Paty de Clam who conspired all and conducted all. His hand was betrayed by its absurd means. Then, it was General De Boisdeffre, it was General Gonse, it was General Billot himself, who were obliged to discharge the commander, since they cannot allow recognition of Dreyfus’s innocence without the department of war collapsing under public contempt. And the beautiful result of this extraordinary situation is that the honest man there, Major Picquart, who only did his duty, became the victim of ridicule and punishment. O justice, what dreadful despair grips the heart! One might just as well say that he was the forger, that he manufactured the carte-télegramme to convict Esterhazy. But, good God! why? with what aim? give a motive. Is he also paid by the Jews? The joke of the story is that he was in fact an anti-Semite. Yes! we attend this infamous spectacle, of the lost men of debts and crimes upon whom one proclaims innocence, while one attacks honor, a man with a spotless life! When a society does this, it falls into decay.
Here is thus, Mr. President, the Esterhazy affair: a culprit whose name it was a question of clearing. For almost two months, we have been able to follow hour by hour the beautiful work. I abbreviate, because it is not here that a summary of the history’s extensive pages will one day be written out in full. We thus saw General De Pellieux, then the commander of Ravary, lead an investigation in which the rascals are transfigured and decent people are dirtied. Then, the council of war was convened. ⁂
How could one hope that a council of war would demolish what a council of war had done?
I do not even mention the always possible choice of judges. Isn’t the higher idea of discipline, which is in the blood of these soldiers, enough to cancel their capacity for equity? Who says discipline breeds obedience? When the Minister of War, the overall chief, established publicly, with the acclamations of the national representation, the authority of the final decision; you want a council of war to give him a formal denial? Hierarchically, that is impossible. General Billot influenced the judges by his declaration, and they judged as they must under fire, without reasoning. The preconceived opinion that they brought to their seats, is obviously this one: “Dreyfus was condemned for crime of treason by a council of war, he is thus guilty; and we, a council of war, cannot declare him innocent, for we know that to recognize Esterhazy’s guilt would be to proclaim the innocence of Dreyfus.” Nothing could make them leave that position.
They delivered an iniquitous sentence that will forever weigh on our councils of war, sullying all their arrests from now with suspicion. The first council of war could have been foolish; the second was inevitably criminal. Its excuse, I repeat it, was that the supreme chief had spoken, declaring the thing considered to be unassailable, holy and higher than men, so that inferiors could not say the opposite. One speaks to us about the honor of the army, that we should like it, respect it. Ah! admittedly, yes, the army which would rise to the first threat, which would defend the French ground, it is all the people, and we have for it only tenderness and respect. But it is not a question of that, for which we precisely want dignity, in our need for justice. It is about the sword, the Master that one will give us tomorrow perhaps. And do not kiss devotedly the handle of the sword, by god!
I have shown in addition: the Dreyfus affair was the affair of the department of war, a High Command officer, denounced by his comrades of the High Command, condemned under the pressure of the heads of the High Command. Once again, it cannot restore his innocence without all the High Command being guilty. Also the offices, by all conceivable means, by press campaigns, by communications, by influences, protected Esterhazy only to convict Dreyfus a second time. What sweeping changes should the republican government should give to this [Jesuitery], as General Billot himself calls it! Where is the truly strong ministry of wise patriotism that will dare to reforge and to renew all? What of people I know who, faced with the possibility of war, tremble of anguish knowing in what hands lies national defense! And what a nest of base intrigues, gossips and dilapidations has this crowned asylum become, where the fate of fatherland is decided! One trembles in face of the terrible day that there has just thrown the Dreyfus affair, this human sacrifice of an unfortunate, a “dirty Jew”! Ah! all that was agitated insanity there and stupidity, imaginations insane, practices of low police force, manners of inquisition and tyranny, good pleasure of some non-commissioned officers putting their boots on the nation, returning in its throat its cry of truth and justice, under the lying pretext and sacrilege of the reason of State.
And it is a yet another crime to have [pressed on ?] the filthy press, to have let itself defend by all the rabble of Paris, so that the rabble triumphs insolently in defeat of law and simple probity. It is a crime to have accused those who wished for a noble France, at the head of free and just nations, of troubling her, when one warps oneself the impudent plot to impose the error, in front of the whole world. It is a crime to mislay the opinion, to use for a spiteful work this opinion, perverted to the point of becoming delirious. It is a crime to poison the small and the humble, to exasperate passions of reaction and intolerance, while taking shelter behind the odious antisemitism, from which, if not cured, the great liberal France of humans rights will die. It is a crime to exploit patriotism for works of hatred, and it is a crime, finally, to turn into to sabre the modern god, when all the social science is with work for the nearest work of truth and justice.
This truth, this justice, that we so passionately wanted, what a distress to see them thus souffletées, more ignored and more darkened! I suspect the collapse which must take place in the heart of Mr. Scheurer-Kestner, and I believe well that he will end up feeling remorse for not having acted revolutionarily, the day of questioning at the Senate, by releasing all the package, [for all to throw to bottom]. He was the great honest man, the man of his honest life, he believed that the truth sufficed for itself, especially when it seemed as bright as the full day. What good is to turn all upside down when the sun was soon to shine? And it is for this trustful neutrality for which he is so cruelly punished. The same for Major Picquart, who, for a feeling of high dignity, did not want to publish the letters of General Gonse. These scruples honour it more especially as, while there remained respectful discipline, its superiors covered it with mud, informed themselves its lawsuit, in the most unexpected and outrageous manner. There are two victims, two good people, two simple hearts, who waited for God while the devil acted. And one even saw, for Major Picquart, this wretched thing: a French court, after having let the rapporteur charge a witness publicly, to show it of all the faults, made the closed door, when this witness was introduced to be explained and defend himself. I say that this is another crime and that this crime will stir up universal conscience. Decidedly, the military tribunals have a singular idea of justice.
Such is thus the simple truth, Mr. President, and it is appalling, it will remain a stain for your presidency. I very much doubt that you have no capacity in this affair, that you are the prisoner of the Constitution and your entourage. You do not have of them less one to have of man, about which you will think, and which you will fulfill. It is not, moreover, which I despair less of the world of the triumph. I repeat it with a more vehement certainty: the truth marches on and nothing will stop it. Today, the affair merely starts, since today only the positions are clear: on the one hand, the culprits who do not want the light to come; the other, the carriers of justice who will give their life to see it come. I said it elsewhere, and I repeat it here: when one locks up the truth under ground, it piles up there, it takes there a force such of explosion, that, the day when it bursts, it makes everything leap out with it. We will see, if we do not prepare for later, the most resounding of disasters.
But this letter is long, Mr. President, and it is time to conclude.
I accuse Major Du Paty de Clam as the diabolic workman of the miscarriage of justice, without knowing, I have wanted to believe it, and of then defending his harmful work, for three years, by the guiltiest and most absurd of machinations.
I accuse General Mercier of being an accomplice, if by weakness of spirit, in one of greatest iniquities of the century.
I accuse General Billot of having held in his hands the unquestionable evidence of Dreyfus’s innocence and of suppressing it, guilty of this crime that injures humanity and justice, with a political aim and to save the compromised Chie of High Command.
I accuse General De Boisdeffre and General Gonse as accomplices of the same crime, one undoubtedly by clerical passion, the other perhaps by this spirit of body which makes offices of the war an infallible archsaint.
I accuse General De Pellieux and commander Ravary of performing a rogue investigation, by which I mean an investigation of the most monstrous partiality, of which we have, in the report of the second, an imperishable monument of naive audacity.
I accuse the three handwriting experts, sirs Belhomme, Varinard and Couard, of submitting untrue and fraudulent reports, unless a medical examination declares them to be affected by a disease of sight and judgment.
I accuse the offices of the war of carrying out an abominable press campaign, particularly in the Flash and the Echo of Paris, to mislead the public and cover their fault.
Finally, I accuse the first council of war of violating the law by condemning a defendant with unrevealed evidence, and I accuse the second council of war of covering up this illegality, by order, by committing in his turn the legal crime of knowingly discharging the culprit.
While proclaiming these charges, I am not unaware of subjecting myself to articles 30 and 31 of the press law of July 29, 1881, which punishes the offense of slander. And it is voluntarily that I expose myself.
As for the people I accuse, I do not know them, I never saw them, I have against them neither resentment nor hatred. To me, they are only entities, spirits of social evil. And the act I am hereby accomplishing is only a revolutionary means to hasten the explosion of truth and justice.
I have only one passion, that of the light, in the name of humanity which has suffered so much and is entitled to happiness. My ignited protest is nothing more than the cry of my heart. So may one dare bring me to criminal court, and may the investigation take place in broad daylight!
I am waiting.
Please accept, Mr. President, the assurance of my deep respect.
Translation from: Wikisource
